|Hermes Bar at Antoine's, New Orleans|
(I don't eat oysters, so I can't be trusted to judge.)
I don't know if it makes sense to return to a bar because the experience was sub-par, but I definitely plan to do that with the Hermes Bar. It just has too good of bloodlines for my experience to have been typical.
Web site: http://www.antoines.com/hermes-bar.html - facebook
Reviews: gonola - nola.com - bestofneworleans